As any anime fan knows, the Akira anime is widely considered to be a classic. The animation and quality of the storytelling was groundbreaking at a time when anime was going through a "cheap" phase (think Sailor Moon... ugh). It still looks good, even today, almost 30 years after it's release.
But before the anime, there was of course the manga. And all six volumes of Katsuhiro Otomo's Akira ended up being my read for book club this month.
I'm going to do my best to not make this simply a comparison of the manga to the anime. Because let me say right up front, as much as Akira is an amazing film, it absolutely pales in comparison to the incredible genius of the manga. The movie is so different as to be hardly even the same story. Many events are skipped, or even replaced by entirely different events in the film. Characters of significant importance in the books are nearly or totally missing from the film. They are just not the same thing, and that's about as much as I want to say about that.
Back to the manga. Akira was dystopian before dystopian was cool, a story about a Tokyo which experiences a societal collapse after an unexplained war. Lurking in the streets we find the protagonist Kaneda (a delinquent teen biker) and his gang of fellow miscreants, including the aggressive young Tetsuo. Kaneda and Tetsuo become wrapped up in a complex web of government secrets, revolutionaries and supernaturally powered children after Tetsuo has a close encounter with the latter. Teaming up with revolutionary Kei and her aunt Chiyoko, Kaneda tries to both simultaneously reach out to, and attempt to destroy Tetsuo after he unleashes the incredible destructive force of Akira.
Spanning over 1800 pages, the story arc for Akira is very long, complex, and highly detailed. In addition to the adventures (and occasional antics) of Kaneda and Kei, we also see perspectives of the Colonel and his military forces, as well as scientists who would attempt to control the Akira phenomena. In addition to the incredibly rich storytelling and plot, the visuals in Akira are simultaneously beautiful and highly disturbing. There are scenes of beautiful cityscapes with incredible detail, as well as scenes of stomach-churing gore. Taken together, this makes Akira an enticing, fascinating, and very worthwhile read, but not one for the faint of heart.
Overall, I found Akira to be one of the most exceptional graphic novels I have ever read. The detail, incredible storyline, fast-paced plot (for the most part, Book 4 drags a little bit), and beautiful art all combine to make for an exciting story. I highly recommend Akira to anyone who enjoys graphic novels, or a nice violent dystopian thriller.
Showing posts with label fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fiction. Show all posts
Tuesday, 28 April 2015
Tuesday, 11 June 2013
Patricia Wrede's "Thirteenth Child" (book review)
I have to admit, I have been very lax lately in my reading of books for younger teens. I'm so keen on the 15-18 older teen books that I've been reading them almost exclusively over the last few months. So recently, when I was at the library with no particular books in mind, I decided to peruse the books aimed at the 12-14 crowd. And that is where I picked up Patricia Wrede's Thirteenth Child.
Thirteenth Child is difficult to classify in terms of its genre. It could be called a fantasy book, or magical realism, or historical fiction, or perhaps most aptly, alternative historical fiction. Thirteenth Child (and the series that follows it) is set in the early days of the American Wild West. Except the frontier is populated with a wild variety of magical and non-magical creatures, as well as some ice-age holdovers like mammoths and sabre-toothed tigers. And the creatures are not the only ones who possess magical abilities, humans possess these abilities as well to varying degrees.
Wrede does an excellent job of keeping enough historical accuracy to make the time period recognizable, but at the same time integrating these interesting, magical aspects of the storyline. The story's heroine, Eff, is considered by some to be an unfortunate, cursed thirteenth child. The story follows Eff as she leaves her home community at a very young age, and strives to leave behind the stigma of her birth order and prove herself to not only be a good person, but one who is safe for others to be around. The story covers a fairly large stretch of time, starting with Eff at age five and ending at age 18. While I found some of the progression through time to be a bit lurching, this doesn't damage the overall quality of the story.
I very much enjoyed Wrede's descriptions of the people, settlements and creatures in this re-imagined America. There is just the right amount of history and magic in this tale to make it approachable and appealing to younger teens. And with Eff's brother Lan and his friend William filling in substantial roles, and getting into several serious misadventures, this work has appeal to teen boys as well as girls. Overall, Thirteenth Child is an engaging story, and I will likely give the sequels a try as well.
Happy Reading. :)
| I love the cover! |
Thirteenth Child is difficult to classify in terms of its genre. It could be called a fantasy book, or magical realism, or historical fiction, or perhaps most aptly, alternative historical fiction. Thirteenth Child (and the series that follows it) is set in the early days of the American Wild West. Except the frontier is populated with a wild variety of magical and non-magical creatures, as well as some ice-age holdovers like mammoths and sabre-toothed tigers. And the creatures are not the only ones who possess magical abilities, humans possess these abilities as well to varying degrees.
Wrede does an excellent job of keeping enough historical accuracy to make the time period recognizable, but at the same time integrating these interesting, magical aspects of the storyline. The story's heroine, Eff, is considered by some to be an unfortunate, cursed thirteenth child. The story follows Eff as she leaves her home community at a very young age, and strives to leave behind the stigma of her birth order and prove herself to not only be a good person, but one who is safe for others to be around. The story covers a fairly large stretch of time, starting with Eff at age five and ending at age 18. While I found some of the progression through time to be a bit lurching, this doesn't damage the overall quality of the story.
I very much enjoyed Wrede's descriptions of the people, settlements and creatures in this re-imagined America. There is just the right amount of history and magic in this tale to make it approachable and appealing to younger teens. And with Eff's brother Lan and his friend William filling in substantial roles, and getting into several serious misadventures, this work has appeal to teen boys as well as girls. Overall, Thirteenth Child is an engaging story, and I will likely give the sequels a try as well.
Happy Reading. :)
Wednesday, 16 January 2013
Jessica Grant's "Come, Thou Tortoise" (a review)
"I would not say no to a tortoise."
Generally speaking, books don't usually make me feel feelings. I don't get scared at the scary parts, I don't laugh out loud at the funny parts and I certainly don't get all weepy at the sad parts. Maybe this makes me a monster. Or maybe I'm just a cool customer. Or maybe I'm far too aware that fiction is fiction, and in fact not real. I'm not really sure.
But what I do know is that if a book DOES make me feel something, then usually it is a damn good book.
Newfoundland author Jessica Grant's Come, Thou Tortoise is in fact one of these few damn good books.
Set in Portland and Newfoundland, Tortoise tells the story of a young woman "of low IQ" named Audrey who is called home when her father falls into a coma. Forced to leave her pet tortoise behind, the story is told through the perspectives of both Audrey and Winnifred the tortoise. Without giving too much away, their adventures become a heartbreaking yet uplifting story about varying degrees of the truth, change, and the nature of family.
Reading the sections told from Audrey's perspective are incredibly interesting. The language style of her character does not use question marks, proper capitalization or quotation marks. And while I found this type of style to be completely aggravating in Mark Haddon's The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime, in the case of Tortoise it just seems to fit so well. I think in Haddon's case it just seemed so contrived, whereas the voice of Audrey comes through with so much clarity even without punctuation to indicate internal dialogue vs. spoken elements.
Tortoise is truly funny. Audrey's literal interpretations of almost everything couple well with the bizarre cast of family and neighbours that inhabit her world. Her misunderstandings are the fodder for many of the most humorous moments, although Winnifred the tortoise seems also to have a bit of an acerbic wit about her. But the book is also incredibly poignant. The full scale of the affection that Audrey's family and friends hold for her is only slowly revealed over the course of the work, but by the end I was full of very rare feelings about this work. There are moments in this story with so much pathos; moments where Audrey could easily give up. The incredible honesty and stubbornness in her character in these moments of true despair was very inspiring. I haven't rooted for a character this much in a long time. Jessica Grant does an amazing job of really pulling in the reader to not only an interesting story but into the mind of a brave young woman who seems so very nearly real by the end of the story. And thankfully (I think it would have broke my heart if it hadn't!) Tortoise ends on a happy note.
I haven't been able to think of a single meaningful criticism for this work. And so I don't think I will criticize at all this time around. Jessica Grant has crafted a story that is amusing, compelling and very moving. I would recommend this book to just about everyone. Try reading the first chapter, and by the time Audrey has locked herself an airplane's bathroom after stealing the gun from an air marshal, you won't be able to put it down.
And for those of you who have already read Come, Thou Tortoise... be Qantas.
But what I do know is that if a book DOES make me feel something, then usually it is a damn good book.
Newfoundland author Jessica Grant's Come, Thou Tortoise is in fact one of these few damn good books.
Set in Portland and Newfoundland, Tortoise tells the story of a young woman "of low IQ" named Audrey who is called home when her father falls into a coma. Forced to leave her pet tortoise behind, the story is told through the perspectives of both Audrey and Winnifred the tortoise. Without giving too much away, their adventures become a heartbreaking yet uplifting story about varying degrees of the truth, change, and the nature of family.
Reading the sections told from Audrey's perspective are incredibly interesting. The language style of her character does not use question marks, proper capitalization or quotation marks. And while I found this type of style to be completely aggravating in Mark Haddon's The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime, in the case of Tortoise it just seems to fit so well. I think in Haddon's case it just seemed so contrived, whereas the voice of Audrey comes through with so much clarity even without punctuation to indicate internal dialogue vs. spoken elements.
Tortoise is truly funny. Audrey's literal interpretations of almost everything couple well with the bizarre cast of family and neighbours that inhabit her world. Her misunderstandings are the fodder for many of the most humorous moments, although Winnifred the tortoise seems also to have a bit of an acerbic wit about her. But the book is also incredibly poignant. The full scale of the affection that Audrey's family and friends hold for her is only slowly revealed over the course of the work, but by the end I was full of very rare feelings about this work. There are moments in this story with so much pathos; moments where Audrey could easily give up. The incredible honesty and stubbornness in her character in these moments of true despair was very inspiring. I haven't rooted for a character this much in a long time. Jessica Grant does an amazing job of really pulling in the reader to not only an interesting story but into the mind of a brave young woman who seems so very nearly real by the end of the story. And thankfully (I think it would have broke my heart if it hadn't!) Tortoise ends on a happy note.
I haven't been able to think of a single meaningful criticism for this work. And so I don't think I will criticize at all this time around. Jessica Grant has crafted a story that is amusing, compelling and very moving. I would recommend this book to just about everyone. Try reading the first chapter, and by the time Audrey has locked herself an airplane's bathroom after stealing the gun from an air marshal, you won't be able to put it down.
And for those of you who have already read Come, Thou Tortoise... be Qantas.
Thursday, 20 December 2012
Oscar Wilde's "The Picture of Dorian Gray" (a review)
"Thus conscience does make cowards of us all."
- William Shakespeare
As I've said before, and I'm sure I'll say again, I get nervous when it comes time to review the classics. Who am I to doubt or impugn the works of the late, the great, the canonized and the deified juggernauts of literature? I don't even have a master's degree in English... but I do have an MLIS, which at the very least qualifies me as an avid consumer and promoter of books, if not a suitable judge of their character and quality. But that aside, I still find it hard to offer criticism to works which have not only stood the test of time, but have found their way into our collective consciousness to the point that themes of these works have become the tropes and memes of everyday life and contemporary entertainment.
And today, the case in point for all of this is Oscar Wilde's The Picture of Dorian Gray.
Even if you have not actively sat down and read this novel, you already know the story. A young man, in the bloom and vigor of his youth, sits for a portrait. The beautiful result moves him not to delight but despair, and he makes the now cliched "deal with the devil" that the portrait shall age in his place. A lifetime of debauchery follows, with the painting baring the scars and wrinkles of the man's misdeeds. And of course, all ends tragically.
This story has been adapted, appropriated and otherwise borrowed from so much for other books and films that it is a very well-known theme. As a result, I went into Wilde's work already knowing what would happen and how it would end*. I don't have this problem with most of the books I decide to review. Consequently, I'm going to set aside any criticism about the premise of the story (which obviously has been good enough to be repeated so often), and focus instead on some of the other elements of the work such as the character development and pacing.
* As a side note: I find it strange and somewhat hilarious that my strongest exposure to this story prior the reading the novel was Brian De Palma's film The Phantom of the Paradise, which crosses the stories of Dorian Gray, The Phantom of the Opera and the legendary tale of Faust. It's a very strange B-movie with a great soundtrack courtesy of Paul Williams, I recommend it.
| Damn fine show-tunes. |
First of all, this book is so very, very reflective of Oscar Wilde and his fate. Dorian Gray is the consummate dandy (a term which I feel is almost impossible to describe Wilde without employing), enjoying a life of relaxing hobbies, socializing, and focusing incessantly on physical appearance. Scandal and gossip abound for both Wilde and his fictional counterpart. And while The Picture of Dorian Gray was written before Wilde's imprisonment and exile, it seems quite prophetic in all these regards. The difference being that Dorian Gray falls from grace in a much less catastrophic fashion, maintaining his unholy outward appearance while his moral structure and social life slowly begin to crumble.
| Oscar, King of the Dandies. |
Interesting parallels between author and character aside, the character of Dorian Gray is quite the tabula rasa at the beginning of the story. He's a vacuous pretty-boy with not a care in the world, until he is introduced to Harry (Lord Henry). Harry is not only a corrupting factor in Gray's life, but is very nearly the devil himself. It is Harry who whispers the seeds of malcontent in Gray's ear and plants the initial buds of doubt. It is Harry who introduces Gray to a lifestyle heavy with temptation and sin. Without Harry, Gray would not have struck his unholy bargain that the painting would age in his stead. And while Harry seems to do none of these things out of malice, his impact on Dorian Gray is as undeniable as if it he had been purposefully leading him astray. As a realistic story, the devil is never directly portrayed or communicated with when Gray makes his fateful trade, but Harry seems to suit the role just a bit too well for it to be coincidental.
Generally speaking, the pacing in The Picture of Dorian Grey is a bit unusual. The first segments of time pass very slowly, until Dorian Gray takes interest in the actress Sibyl. From there the pacing picks up a bit, until the reader is slammed against the truly bizarre chapter which details the contents of the book which Gray is given by Harry. And while this strange chapter seems to demarcate the two halves of the story, I found it's long-winded, overly descriptive passages to be pretty much unreadable. I ended up skipping long sections of the chapter (which was over 50 pages long in my version). Following this chapter we move several years ahead, and pacing resumes a somewhat regular flow. While I appreciated the impact and need to go into detail about Dorian Gray's first act of cruelty (that against Sibyl), I felt that this section of the novel could have been a bit shorter in order that the reader be moved into the action a bit more quickly. The first chapters are a bit dry and I hope that not too many readers have given up on this novel too soon because of that.
Dorian Gray himself is both frustrating and relateable. While part of me wanted to shake him for being a classically-trained asshole for good parts of the book, another part of me wanted to see him redeemed, repentant, and relieved of his curse. These mixed feelings are the sign of true character development. When Gray's vengeful stalker is killed, it is both a breath of relief and a moment of annoyance that Gray had escaped punishment for his crimes yet again. Being able to elicit such strong reactions in the reader is a true sign of a great writer, which Wilde doubtlessly was.
Wilde, like his character Dorian Gray, was also subject to a tragic end, one very much unsuitable for someone with such a creative, provocative writing style and imagination. And while his works are few, I've enjoyed this one immensely, and would highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys fiction and wants to read one of the great common themes of literature couched in a rich cast of characters.
Tuesday, 13 November 2012
Ally Condie's "Crossed" (review)
Last week I wrote a review of the first, titular book in
Ally Condie’s Matched trilogy (you
can read it here if you’d like). And of
course THAT THING happened where you can’t stop thinking about a book until you
get your hands on the next one in the series.
Of course I had a feeling this would happen. But rather than wait to review the whole
series, I decided to do individual reviews for each book. This is partially because I didn’t want to
forget any of the details, and partially because the last book in the series, Reached, has only just been released
today. And I’m like number 63 in line on
the library holds list for that one. So
the show must go on.
Crossed is the
second book in the Matched trilogy. My main complaint against the otherwise
delightful first book was the pacing. It
just seemed to lack action. The second
book definitely amps up the action quotient, showing the struggles of both Ky
and Cassia by splitting the perspective of the book between these two with
alternating chapters featuring their points of view. Ky and his brethren are sent to the front
lines of a war that is not so much being fought as staged, and there is no
shortage of action as he comes under fire and is forced to make difficult
choices. Cassia’s story also gets
significantly more action packed as she pursues Ky across unknown
territory. I enjoyed this dual
perspective because it allowed for the story to effectively advance, despite
the geographic distance between Ky and Cassia for a good portion of the
book. However, at times I found that I
was confused as to whose perspective I was reading. Because some of the chapters are so very
short (only one page!), I seemed to forget that the perspective had
changed. This was particularly prominent
in scenes where Ky and Cassia are talking to each other, it is hard to
determine whose side the reader is viewing at those times. Despite this, I don’t think the story could
have been effectively told without using this tool, even though it was sloppily
used at times.
The new characters were a very welcome addition to the story
as well. Indie and Eli provide a bit
more depth and variety of emotional responses in the characters, which was not
seen in the first book. Indie especially
seems to contain all the anger that Cassia and Ky hold about their lives, but
are unable to express. As Eli embodies
the innocence of their previous lives/childhoods, I found it appropriate that
he is left behind as the rest of the characters push for the Rising. One character that does not get its full due
in Crossed is the Society. And while I appreciate that this part of the
story is set in the fringes of the Society’s reach, I found it bizarre that the
characters are able to complete so many of their actions without the supposedly
omnipotent and omniscient Society noticing.
But maybe this gets addressed in Reached.
Overall, Crossed is
a very fitting and exciting continuation of the series. And, most of all, I appreciated not being
left with a cliffhanger ending! The
ending (which I shan’t spoil) leaves the reader wanting more, but does not
invoke the total desperation a la Hunger
Games where you feel like you just might freak out and/or cry if you don’t
find out what happens next. But I do
have high expectations and a nagging urge to read the last book, Reached.
But for now I wait for the library to deliver, like it
always does, in good time.
Monday, 5 November 2012
Ally Condie's "Matched"... or, go ask Ally. (review)
"One pill makes you larger and one pill makes you small. And the ones that mother gives you don't do anything at all."
- Jefferson Airplane's "White Rabbit"
We selected dystopian fiction for book club this month. For me, this was pretty much like winning the genre lottery. Next to my deep-seated love for magical realism, dystopian runs a close second in my favorite genre race. I love the world building, I love the despotic governments, I love the underdog, (often underage) heroes/heroines, and I ESPECIALLY love that there is no guarantee of a happy ending. When you're reading a dystopian story, anything goes. Anything and everything could happen. I absolutely adore the flexibility that this genre has that comes with this lack of rules. It's not bound by the historical accuracy of westerns and historical fiction. It is not bound by the required good feelings and happy endings of romance novels. And most curious of all, it seems that any level of violence becomes pretty much completely acceptable if the novel is dystopian, even if the intended audience is children/teens.
So for dystopian month, I selected a book that I have been itching to read for months. With the impeding release of Reached, I thought it would be a fantastic time to read Ally Condie's popular triology Matched, so I read the titular book of this series.
Now let me preface this review by saying I have read A LOT of dystopian works. And while that doesn't make me an expert, it makes me an avid reader, super-huge fan, and a pretty picky clientele. I was very intrigued by the whole premise of the mistaken match, and devoured Matched over the course of about four days (this is incredibly fast for me, I am a very slow and deliberate reader).
The first thing that I noticed about Matched is the simplicity of the language. Now while the lack of variety in adjectives or five-point words could be annoying for the reader, I treated the level of the writing to reflect the context of the story. The characters' restricted access to literature and other forms of expression explain the simplistic verbiage; it is written as the first-person protagonist Cassia would speak. It is rife with simple words and short sentences which are low on detail. But every now and then there is a sentence that will pop out as being much more complex, and these are instances where Cassia is questioning the Society. As a result, I found this style of writing to be highly reflective of the mental state of the characters.
However, I do have to complain about the slow pace of the work. While I still found it highly engaging, I worry that this may have been because I love the genre so much and less that I was desperate to find out about what happened next. The story feels like it is dragging its feet a bit. And while this was probably to allow for more character development and the progress of the relationships between Cassia, Zander and Ky, I feel like the story could have used a few less of the moments where not a lot is happening. Apparently the pacing improves and things get a bit more fast-paced in the later books of the series (which I have on hold at the library!).
Matched reminded me of several other books that I've read. I felt that it is a bit like a combination of Suzanne Collins' The Hunger Games, Aldous Huxley's Brave New World. The perspective is like The Hunger Games in reverse; we see the world of the privileged city dwellers instead of the abused outliers living in rural regions. And Brave New World came to mind because of the societal control aspects, the constant monitoring and assigned careers, as well as the plight of those marked from birth as unacceptable.
In terms of the violence that is usually found in dystopian works, I found that Matched was actually pretty non-violent and generally low-key when it came to physical threats towards the characters. But keep in mind that this is in comparison to the hyper-violence in comparable works including The Hunger Games and Patrick Ness' Chaos Walking triology. Much more is implied in Matched, which I think greatly compliments the aspects of the Society as being both a menace and a protector, and fits well with the bland wording as well. The reader is not quite sure exactly what sort of fate will befall a citizen if they fall out of favor with society. And not knowing/not seeing the evil and the violence quite as much helps to make the book that much creepier and enticing.
So in conclusion, I would say that Matched is not the scariest, nor the most violent, nor the most eloquently written dystopian fiction work that I have ever read. But it is exceptionally well-balanced, and creates those feelings within the reader that only seem to come with dystopian works... the little worry in the back of one's mind that this could happen to us.
Watch for a follow-up review of the next book in this triology, Crossed, in the near future.
So for dystopian month, I selected a book that I have been itching to read for months. With the impeding release of Reached, I thought it would be a fantastic time to read Ally Condie's popular triology Matched, so I read the titular book of this series.
Now let me preface this review by saying I have read A LOT of dystopian works. And while that doesn't make me an expert, it makes me an avid reader, super-huge fan, and a pretty picky clientele. I was very intrigued by the whole premise of the mistaken match, and devoured Matched over the course of about four days (this is incredibly fast for me, I am a very slow and deliberate reader).
The first thing that I noticed about Matched is the simplicity of the language. Now while the lack of variety in adjectives or five-point words could be annoying for the reader, I treated the level of the writing to reflect the context of the story. The characters' restricted access to literature and other forms of expression explain the simplistic verbiage; it is written as the first-person protagonist Cassia would speak. It is rife with simple words and short sentences which are low on detail. But every now and then there is a sentence that will pop out as being much more complex, and these are instances where Cassia is questioning the Society. As a result, I found this style of writing to be highly reflective of the mental state of the characters.
However, I do have to complain about the slow pace of the work. While I still found it highly engaging, I worry that this may have been because I love the genre so much and less that I was desperate to find out about what happened next. The story feels like it is dragging its feet a bit. And while this was probably to allow for more character development and the progress of the relationships between Cassia, Zander and Ky, I feel like the story could have used a few less of the moments where not a lot is happening. Apparently the pacing improves and things get a bit more fast-paced in the later books of the series (which I have on hold at the library!).
Matched reminded me of several other books that I've read. I felt that it is a bit like a combination of Suzanne Collins' The Hunger Games, Aldous Huxley's Brave New World. The perspective is like The Hunger Games in reverse; we see the world of the privileged city dwellers instead of the abused outliers living in rural regions. And Brave New World came to mind because of the societal control aspects, the constant monitoring and assigned careers, as well as the plight of those marked from birth as unacceptable.
In terms of the violence that is usually found in dystopian works, I found that Matched was actually pretty non-violent and generally low-key when it came to physical threats towards the characters. But keep in mind that this is in comparison to the hyper-violence in comparable works including The Hunger Games and Patrick Ness' Chaos Walking triology. Much more is implied in Matched, which I think greatly compliments the aspects of the Society as being both a menace and a protector, and fits well with the bland wording as well. The reader is not quite sure exactly what sort of fate will befall a citizen if they fall out of favor with society. And not knowing/not seeing the evil and the violence quite as much helps to make the book that much creepier and enticing.
So in conclusion, I would say that Matched is not the scariest, nor the most violent, nor the most eloquently written dystopian fiction work that I have ever read. But it is exceptionally well-balanced, and creates those feelings within the reader that only seem to come with dystopian works... the little worry in the back of one's mind that this could happen to us.
Watch for a follow-up review of the next book in this triology, Crossed, in the near future.
Wednesday, 5 September 2012
Frank Herbert's "Dune"... or, I've got sand in my pants. (review)
"Mood? What has mood to do with it? You fight when the necessity arises — no matter the mood! Mood's a thing for cattle or making love or playing the baliset. It's not for fighting."
Oh boy. There's always a problem when you decide to take on a classic or canonical work of a genre for review. Not only is there the weight of history and time to contend with, along with nearly universal respect and admiration, but you have to occasionally disagree with people who obviously know more about literature than I (or you probably) do.
| Arthur C. Clarke dares you to disagree! |
Let's take for example Arthur C. Clarke. Of Frank Herbert's Dune, he said "I know nothing comparable to it except Lord of the Rings". And who am I to argue with Arthur C. (friggin' Space Odyssey) Clarke? I'm not going to disagree at all. This is not only because I wouldn't want the undead wrath of Mr.Clarke or any other hardcore Dune fans to descend upon me, but also because I agree with this statement. It is apt. Dune is just like Lord of the Rings... in all the good ways and bad.
Firstly, I have to admit that Dune is completely epic. It's got the whole shebang: scheming royalty, political intrigue, bitter betrayal, star-crossed love, holy war, lots of killing, etc. It is all the makings of a really great book. And for the most part, Dune is a great book. But it would be a really fucking boring review if all I did was agree with his zombie-highness Mr.Clarke and left it at that. Frank Herbert gathers all the most epic bits from literature and puts them into one 500 page tome.
BUT.
Dune suffers from the same terrible flaw that Lord of the Rings does when it comes to assembling the mountain of kickass-ness into an actual story. And that is that when Herbert and Tolkien put their stories together, they apparently got really bored and just sort of slapped things together at the last minute when they got tired of writing. YOU KNOW EXACTLY WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT. Tolkien took like a hundred and fifty pages just to get the hobbits to leave the goddamn Shire. It was like 300 pages in before we got the hell out of the merciless nonsensical clutches of Tom Bombadil. Then after the story gets rolling he writes like 5000 more pages of awesome high fantasy adventureness. And readers everywhere are completely enraptured and in love and oh my god they finally threw the ring into Mount Doom and yes victory woooo go hobbits! And then it's over. Despite the fact that it took like a billion pages to walk into Mordor (this is because one does not simply walk into Mordor, of course), it then takes them like 20 pages to walk home. What. the. hell. Did they discover that if they took the back door it turns out that the Shire was in the backyard or something?! And then Saruman is there at the end and oh my god we just do not talk about that abortion of an ending.
| The view from Frodo's back porch? |
But I digress.
My point is that Frank Herbert's Dune suffers from the same breed of terrible timing. Aside from a big time skip about 2/3 of the way into the book, the rest of the story dodders along at a Tolkienesque pace. Lost in the desert? No problem, we can go on that for like 70 pages. Time for the epic final battle? Oh, you get like ONE CHAPTER to get that shit done. And then everyone dies! (There I ruined the book for you.) Dune runs to its conclusion after jauntily strolling through the rest of the story. And yes I know there are more books but all the hardcore fans (including my mom) say that they are awful and not worth reading as much as the first one.
Speaking of the time when everyone died... SPOILER!... I find it incredibly messed up that Paul does not seem to give a mouse fart that his kid is dead at the end of the book. I know it's because Paul is a Fremen-Super-Saiyan and is above feelings and all that but seriously, HIS KID IS DEAD. Considering how believable the rest of the characters are in terms of their motivations and actions, I found that this pretty much ruined Paul/Muad'dib/Usul/whatever for me. Even after his dad the Duke died and he didn't cry, I found that more believable because they were fleeing for their lives. But at the end it's Paul holding all the cards and he's got no tears left for his kid. It is just too much to believe, even for super emotion controlling Bene Gesserit powered Paul.
The only other thing that bugged me about Dune is the mediocre female character roles. This probably has a great deal to do with the fact that the book was written in 1965 though, so I can almost excuse it. Jessica is certainly one of the most interesting characters in the book, but I find the other women's roles to be so small that I can barely even discern if they have personalities beyond their housekeeping skills (this is especially the case for Chani, who I really wanted to like!).
Now, the positives. Yes, the book is good. In fact, it's really good. I am a very slow reader, so if I sit down to read then I am making a serious commitment to spend time with the book. And Dune just kept pulling me back to read more. The imagery in descriptions of Arrakis the dune planet are absolutely fantastic. The characters (for the most part) are lively, believable and inspire pathos. Layers of personal growth are stacked on each of the main characters as the story progresses, which really helps with the time skip in the last 1/3 of the book.
Last, but not least, I love sandworms. I could not stop picturing the sandworms! I wish that they had been a bigger part of the story, and hoped that the final battle finale would see Paul riding into town on a sandworm, squashing Harkonnens all along the way. Not quite that epic though. As I was reading, I realized that my mental image of the sandworms matches up closely with the box cover from the 1980's North American import ripoff of Hayao Miyazaki's classic anime Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind. The movie was massively cut and redubbed and redistributed in North America under the name Warriors of the Wind, and is now considered a complete and total abomination since the release of the full version. But the box is awesome, and it makes me think of Dune.
| Ride the worm!!! |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

